The Captains of April 25: The Reform Frame

Dr. Manuel interviewed six officers of the Reform Frame in April 1991, among them António de Spínola, Carlos Galvão de Melo and Manuel Monge.

Select a name to open the full entry.

The Reform Frame

Carlos Galvão de Melo, Cascais, April 16, 1991
Carlos Galvão de Melo, Cascais, April 16, 1991 ▸

On Tuesday, 16 April 1991, Dr. Manuel took the train from Lisbon out to Cascais to meet Carlos Galvão de Melo at his home. Galvão de Melo spoke at length about Rio Maior. It was familiar ground for him: at the height of the Verão Quente [Hot Summer] of 1975 he had given a fiercely anti-communist speech there, one that parts of the Portuguese right still remember.

That was a large part of why Dr. Manuel had sought him out. In those weeks Rio Maior had become a center of the reaction against the Communist Party, and his father had nearly been killed by a crowd in that same square. He wanted to understand how a market town he had known as a peaceful place could turn so quickly to violence, and who, if anyone, bore responsibility for what happened to his father.

Galvão de Melo was very clear about it: in his view, what happened in the square had been the work of a group of far-left revolutionaries trying to foment a violent revolution. When Dr. Manuel put the same question to Costa Gomes two weeks later, the former president was more cautious. It may have been as Galvão de Melo described it, he said, but it may also have been a setup meant to discredit the left; he had seen reports pointing either way, and a final verdict was difficult.

Dr. Manuel does not expect ever to know fully what happened in Rio Maior that day. He does know that his father’s life was in danger, and that was the only fact that mattered to him at the time, as it still is.

Born on 4 August 1921 in Buarcos, by Figueira da Foz, the son of António Augusto Ferreira de Melo, of Mangualde, and Cecília Rosa Teles de Noronha Galvão, he spent part of his childhood in Aldeia de Oliveira, near Mangualde, studied in Lisbon at the Liceu Camões and the university, and entered the Academia Militar during the Second World War, expecting Portugal to be drawn into it. He graduated in military aeronautics in 1943 and later completed the staff course with distinction. His career took him to NATO headquarters from 1951 to 1954, to Goa from 1954 to 1957 and to command of the Fifteenth Squadron in Porto; he led a mission to Mozambique in 1960, and in Angola the following year he was removed from his post after denouncing irregular dealings involving military aircraft.

Until 1966 he created and directed the Air Force staff course at the Instituto de Altos Estudos, and he then served as military attaché in South Africa from 1966 to 1970 and in Brazil from 1970 to 1973. He had little patience with the way the regime used the Air Force, and a complaint of his about the state of the armed forces was quoted by Álvaro Cunhal himself, which, he later said with a laugh, had brought him considerable popularity.

By 1974 he was a colonel in the reserve, and the captains recalled him on 25 April to sit on the Junta de Salvação Nacional [National Salvation Junta] as the representative of the Air Force, promoting him to general. He was the most conservative member of the Junta, more so even than Spínola; from July 1974 his office oversaw the commission charged with dissolving the PIDE/DGS, the political police, and it was there, by one account, that the failed “silent majority” demonstration of 28 September was prepared. He was removed from the Junta and arrested in the crisis that ended with Spínola’s resignation.

He then turned to elected politics, winning a seat in the Constituent Assembly in 1975 as an independent on the list of the CDS, where his clashes with the Communist and UDP deputies earned him the name o general sem papas na língua [the general who did not mince words]. That same outspokenness eventually led to his break with the CDS, and he stood for president in 1980, winning less than one percent of the vote.

Formal and polite rather than warm, emphatic and grandiloquent in speech, with the looks of an old Hollywood leading man, he rode, played tennis into old age, kept a blog and was still sought out for talks and interviews. In 1993 he co-founded the Portugal–Indonesia Friendship Association, which cost him much of his popularity. He had been made a knight of the Military Order of Avis in 1953 and an officer of the order in 1964, and in 1989 he received the Grand Cross of the Order of Merit of the Federal Republic of Germany. He died at his home in Alcabideche, near Cascais, on 20 March 2008, at the age of eighty-six.

Sanches Osório, Lisbon, April 16, 1991
Sanches Osório, Lisbon, April 16, 1991 ▸

Dr. Manuel met Sanches Osório in Lisbon on Tuesday, 16 April 1991. He was a deeply Catholic man, and it was he who first told Dr. Manuel that the Jesuit priest João Cabral Abranches had celebrated private Mass with President Costa Gomes during the transition, something Costa Gomes himself confirmed in his own interview two weeks later.

José Eduardo Fernandes de Sanches Osório was born in Lisbon in 1941. He took a degree in military engineering, and later one in law at the Universidade de Lisboa, and he taught at the Academia Militar; at twenty-seven he commanded a company of some four hundred men in Angola. A major of engineers in 1974, he was one of the six officers who organized the coup and directed it from the command post at Pontinha, with Otelo Saraiva de Carvalho, Vítor Crespo, Fisher Lopes Pires, Hugo dos Santos and Garcia dos Santos, and he sat on the MFA’s first coordinating committee. After 25 April he served as spokesman of the National Salvation Junta, as director-general of information, and as minister of social communication in the second provisional government, a post he lost after the events of 28 September 1974.

In September 1974 he became secretary-general of the Partido da Democracia Cristã [Christian Democratic Party], a post he held until 1979; he brought the party into contact with the European Union of Christian Democrats and signed the pact between the MFA and the parties over the objections of many in his own party. Aligned with Spínola, he was implicated in the failed coup attempt of 11 March 1975 and fled to Spain, where he joined Spínola’s Movimento Democrático de Libertação de Portugal [Democratic Movement for the Liberation of Portugal]; the Council of the Revolution expelled him from the armed forces, and his party was barred from the elections of April 1975.

That same year he published O Equívoco do 25 de Abril [The Misunderstanding of 25 April], which appeared in Portugal, Spain and Brazil; in it he argued that the Armed Forces Movement, which had enjoyed popular support, had become the instrument of a Communist minority, and he appealed to his fellow officers to recognize the error.

He returned to Portugal the following year and was readmitted to the army in 1977. He joined the CDS in 1979 and sat in the Assembleia da República from 1979 to 1983, first for the CDS, for Lisbon, and later as an independent, for Santarém, after leaving the party in 1982. In 1982 he received the Grand Cross of the Order of Liberty. Asked in 2023 what the country had made of the nearly fifty years since, he answered, Perdemos tempo [We lost time].

General Manuel Monge, in later years
Manuel Monge, Lisbon, April 23, 1991 ▸

Dr. Manuel met Manuel Monge in his Lisbon office on Tuesday, 23 April 1991, and found him incredibly impressive: a man of military, stately bearing and of strength, and at the same time kind, compassionate and understanding, quite open and responsive to every question. He spoke with authority about what happened on 25 April and about the two years of transition that followed, and he was proud of the outcome.

Born in 1938 in Vila Nova de São Bento, in the municipality of Serpa, he had served four tours of duty in the colonial war, two in Angola and two in Guinea, and was a Spínola loyalist; he became disillusioned with the regime’s failure to negotiate an end to the wars and joined the officers’ movement. He belonged to the Movement of Captains and to the MFA’s Coordinating Committee, and as a major he took part in the failed uprising of 16 March 1974 at Caldas da Rainha, the rehearsal for 25 April; arrested and held at the Trafaria prison, he was freed by the revolution itself.

A moderate within the MFA, he later served as military adviser to the President of the Republic and to Mário Soares, held the security portfolio in the Government of Macau, rose to the rank of general, and was the last civil governor of Beja, until 2011.

António de Spínola, Lisbon, April 24, 1991
António de Spínola, Lisbon, April 24, 1991 ▸

Dr. Manuel met António de Spínola on Wednesday, 24 April 1991, at the Ministry of National Defense (Ministério da Defesa Nacional). While he waited, military officers moved busily about. Then, suddenly, a car pulled up, and everything stopped as what appeared to be hundreds of officers stood at attention. Dr. Manuel had no idea what was going on: he was the only one not at attention.

Then a distinguished gentleman wearing a monocle stepped out of the car and came toward him. It was General Spínola. The general asked whether he was Paul Manuel and, when he said that he was, invited him to take a private elevator to his office. Spínola was entirely cordial throughout the visit, and it was all very formal; one of his assistants stayed with them the entire time.

General Spínola heard each question out and answered it fully, with the assurance of a man long accustomed to command. He was quite pleased with democratic Portugal in 1991, and was convinced that he had been right all along, vis-à-vis Caetano, and in his dealings with the more radical members of the MFA; more than once he told Dr. Manuel that his reform plan had in the end proven to be the right course for Portugal.

Dr. Manuel found one of his responses most interesting. Asked what he and Caetano had talked about when power was transferred to him on April 25, 1974, Spínola said the conversation had been quite simple. When they met, Spínola said to Caetano, “Look at the condition you have brought to the country,” and Caetano responded, “This is not the time for recrimination. Power on the street frightens me.”

Born in Estremoz in 1910, Spínola had been governor and commander-in-chief of Portuguese Guinea from 1968 to 1973; named deputy chief of the general staff of the armed forces in January 1974, he published Portugal e o Futuro the following month, arguing that the colonial wars could not be won by military means, and the book soon cost him his post. Named president by the National Salvation Junta after the coup, he resigned on 30 September 1974 over his disputes with the more progressive officers, and after the failed coup attempt of 11 March 1975 he went into exile in Brazil. He later returned to Portugal, was raised to the rank of marshal in 1981, and died on 13 August 1996.

Casanova Ferreira, Lisbon, April 26, 1991
Casanova Ferreira, Lisbon, April 26, 1991 ▸

Dr. Manuel interviewed Casanova Ferreira in his Lisbon office on Friday, 26 April 1991. Casanova Ferreira was gracious, listened closely, and gave lively answers, and he was quite funny.

Luís António de Moura Casanova Ferreira, born in 1931, was an infantry major in 1974 and was most notably linked to the failed uprising of 16 March 1974 at Caldas da Rainha, which led to the coup of 25 April. On the night of 15 to 16 March he met with Otelo Saraiva de Carvalho, Manuel Monge and Armando Ramos, and together they decided to go ahead; when the column from Caldas set out for Lisbon, he and Monge went to meet it and persuaded it to turn back, since the regime was on alert and loyal troops were waiting. He then stayed with the rebels through the siege of the barracks, though colleagues urged him to leave, and was arrested and held at Trafaria with the other officers involved.

Close to Spínola, he had served under him in Guinea-Bissau, where he held his last command before the revolution. Firmly anti-communist, he stood on the right of the Armed Forces Movement after 25 April. He was arrested during the failed right-wing coup attempt of 11 March 1975 and released a week before 25 November. He later commanded the infantry regiment at Abrantes and retired as a colonel. He died in Lisbon on 20 August 2015, at the age of eighty-four.

Jaime Neves, Lisbon, April 29, 1991
Jaime Neves, Lisbon, April 29, 1991 ▸

Dr. Manuel interviewed Jaime Neves in his Lisbon office on Monday, 29 April 1991. Neves was alert throughout, direct and soldierly, and answered each question prudently. He was an impressive military figure, and he spoke about the need for the coup of 25 April 1974 against the dictatorship, and about his opposition to a communist takeover of the government.

Born in the parish of São Dinis, Vila Real, in 1936, he entered the Escola do Exército in 1953 and served five tours of duty in Africa and in India.

His role on 25 November 1975 was vital. As commander of the Commando Regiment at Amadora, working under the coordination of António Ramalho Eanes, Neves and his commandos retook the occupied objectives one by one: by late afternoon they had freed the Air Force installations at Monsanto from the paratroopers who had seized them, that evening they retook the RTP studios, and on the morning of 26 November they obtained the surrender of the Military Police at Ajuda, the last stronghold of the radical left, at the cost of the lives of two commandos and one soldier of the Military Police.

By ending the armed resistance quickly and with so little bloodshed, Neves protected the democratic process that led to the Constitution of April 1976 and the elections that followed, and he helped keep a confrontation inside the armed forces from becoming a civil war. When he died, the Social Democrats, the Socialists and the CDS alike credited him with the consolidation of Portuguese democracy, and General Loureiro dos Santos called him a national hero.

He passed into the reserve in 1981 as a colonel; President Mário Soares made him a grand officer of the Order of the Tower and Sword in 1995, and he was later promoted to major general. He died on 27 January 2013.